Last Updated on October 18, 2021
Imagine mouth-watering waffles for breakfast, a deliciously oozy cheese toastie for lunch, and a perfectly grilled chicken for dinner. What do they have in common? The perfect sandwich toaster. If you want to treat your tastebuds in this way, you don’t have to look far. We found the best toasters for your home!
The Best Sandwich Toasters Reviewed In 2021
We picked this as our top toaster. It’s compact, powerful and versatile. Indeed, you can make imaginative toasted sandwiches with this thing or press the perfect panini. With its hinged lid, the toaster is also user-friendly.
The big size allows you to prepare big items, including ciabatta, pitta, tortillas, and focaccia. You can even make up to four toasties at once! Don’t worry about a messy clean-up because the plates are non-stick, removable and can be placed in the dishwasher.
Other great features include being able to warm tortillas and naan bread, cook crumpets, toast teacakes as well as bagels. The ready-to-cook indicator also lets you know when the hot plates are hot enough to cook your sandwich.
READ NEXT: The best electric can opener you can buy
- Prepares up to 4 sandwiches.
- Compact and easy to use.
- Suitable for all bread products.
- Can be used for making crumpets.
- Easy to clean.
- Can be a bit noisy.
If you liked the previous product but want something that puts you in panini heaven, then this version is the best choice. With its hinged lid and large plates, you can add any thickness panini and cook up to three at once. You can also make sandwiches, so you keep the versatility as well!
The compact toaster has non-stick plates that are easy to clean, a 100W power rating, a cool-touch handle, and it makes café-style crisp sandwiches or paninis.
- Easy to use, clean and store.
- Makes great paninis and sandwiches.
- A safe handle.
- Heat indicator light.
- You can only cook 3 paninis at once if they are small.
This toaster is almost fully dishwasher safe, making it one of the most hassle-free appliances you (as a toastie lover) can wish for. But what else can you expect? After all, you want it to make delicious snacks!
It features extra-large non-stick pockets that allow you to use Ciabatta, Foccacia, or thick slices of hand-cut bread stuffed with anything that you prefer. The quick toaster is also perfect for fruit pastries, omelettes, French toasts and quesadillas. This machine also has variable temperature control to allow you to achieve that perfect browning without burning your sandwich.
READ NEXT: Top rated electric knife sharpener reviews
- Easy to clean.
- Perfect temperature control.
- Suitable for toasties, omelets and fruit pastries.
- Can open the lid while preparing your sandwich.
- The plates are large enough to accommodate even the thickest slice.
- Requires a sligh learning curve.
This press is a stainless steel sandwich maker that specializes in café-style sandwiches and paninis. It allows you to prepare the best toasties like Panini, Focaccia, and Ciabatta. It’s also very compact, so you can take it along on a trip or store it easily in a closet.
You can also look forward to features like great cord storage, a cool-touch handle and an included booklet that is equipped with instructions on how to set it up and prepare various sandwiches as well as paninis. Indeed, the floating hinged top can accommodate sandwiches of varying sizes and thicknesses.
You also don’t need oil or butter because the plates are non-stick. Once you are done cooking, you can also easily wipe them clean.
- Easy to use and clean.
- Can make different size snacks.
- Only suitable for one or two sandwiches.
If you want to dip your senses into a luxury sandwich, then this toaster is the top choice. It can make toasted sandwiches with an exceptional amount of toppings. So, if you dream of a sandwich stuffed to the gills with cheese and bacon, this press is up for the job!
Other features that make this a highly popular press includes neatly sealed borders on your sandwiches, a ready-to-cook indicator, compact size, and dishwasher-safe plates.
- Seals a lot of fillings inside your toasties.
- Suitable for thin or thick sandwiches.
- Non-stick plates.
- Easy to use and clean.
- Non-slip feet.
- The sealed edges can turn out hard.
If you love the idea of a deep-fill sandwich toaster but want to shop around, then here’s another great choice. This appliance creates some of the best deep filled toasted sandwiches. The non-stick plates also eliminate the need for butter and make cleaning a breeze.
You can also look forward to the ridges that cut and seal the sandwiches to prevent ingredients from spilling out. More great features include cool-touch housing, stable feet, a capacity for two sandwiches, a hinged lid with a locking clip, and even heat distribution.
- Seals contents inside sandwich.
- Compact and stylish.
- Quick to heat up.
- Even distribution of heat.
- Easy to use and clean.
- No oil or butter needed.
- Does not allow for a generous amount of fillings unless you use a crustless bread slice.
This toaster serves three major functions. Facilitated by the interchangeable top and bottom hot plates, you can use them as waffle plates, a top and bottom Panini plate and a top and a toasted sandwich grill. All the plates are large and deep enough to accommodate slices of different sizes.
They are also non-stick, making it easy to clean and prevent your sandwich from tearing. Their big size also allows you to make family-sized meals and deep-fill snacks. Finally, with a power rating of 900 watts, you can have your toasties, paninis, grill snacks, and waffles ready in a matter of minutes.
- Multifunctional toaster.
- Features a locking cool-touch handle with a locking hatch.
- The removable plates are non-stick.
- Provides grill, flat, and waffle options.
- Toasts sandwiches quickly.
- The 900W is not high enough to cook other desserts.
This is another dependable toaster if you want perfect paninis, wraps, crumpets and ciabatta. It’s also great at warming pittas, naan bread and croissants. This toaster has a locking lid that features a hinge to allow toasties and waffles of different sizes.
You can look forward to several useful features. The toaster gives you variable temperature control, non-stick plates, a ceramic coating that is scratch resistant and increases cooking speed by 20%.
- Easy to use and clean.
- Durable and scratch resistant.
- Variable heat control makes perfect toasties.
- Easy to store.
- No grill plates.
This deep fill sandwich toaster comes with extra-large non-stick plates that can accommodate two toasties at once. With the powerful 900W heating element, you can have your toasties ready in approximately 4 minutes.
The press is extremely easy and safe to use. For starters, the handle is cool to the touch, a simple locking latch as well as a power on and ready indicator light. Since the plates are non-stick, you are guaranteed perfectly cooked toasties and waffles.
One of the best things you can love about this toaster is the fact that it makes toasties that are 50% bigger than ordinary sandwiches. This is because of the extra deep filling plates. You don’t even cut the bread slices to fit in the sandwich toaster.
- A deep fill sandwich maker.
- You can get your snacks in just 4 minutes.
- Features a locking catch, a cool-touch handle, and non-slip feet.
- The non-stick plates are easy to clean.
- There are no removable plates or grill plates.
This 3-in-1 sandwich maker can do more than just produce magical toasties. For instance, if you want you can use it as a Panini press, a waffle maker or a grill. It has removable plates and they are easy to clean since they have a non-stick coating.
If you love quick and powerful cooking, then the 700W will be a delight. The non-slip feet make it stable on most kitchen surfaces. It’s also very portable so you can take it along when you travel or store it away when you no longer need it.
- Comes with removable plates, grill, waffle, and flat options for perfect toasted sandwiches, paninis and snacks.
- Compact and portable.
- Powerful and quick performance.
- It doesn’t seal the edges of the sandwiches.
Your Buying Guide To Sandwich Toasters
Think of all the toasties you can spoil your family with – if you have the right sandwich toaster. With so many models available, it’s easy to mistakenly purchase something of poor quality or functions that aren’t what you wanted. Our guide is packed with tips to ensure that you find the best toastie maker for your kitchen!
A good toaster will have a stay-cool handle and a lid lock. It also bodes well if the appliance seals the edges of a sandwich so that fillings do not spill and accidentally get into the wrong places.
The Right Plates
Make sure that the plates are at least non-stick. This will prevent burnt sandwiches and also make your toaster a breeze to clean. If you want extras, there are toasters with interchangeable plates that can make waffles or crumpets.
Pick something that suits your needs. Some toasters are deep-fill and perfect if you love stuffed sandwiches while others are small and can toast two sandwiches at a time. But if you need something bigger for your family meals, some toasters are large enough to handle three or four snacks at once.
Q: Which is the Right Sandwich Maker for Me?
A: The right sandwich maker for you depends on several factors including your budget, the size of your family and the kitchen space that you have.
Q: Are the Plates Removable and Dishwasher Safe?
A: Manufacturing companies have their own ways of producing sandwich makers. While some produce sandwich makers with removable and dishwasher safe plates, others do the exact opposite.
Additional Reading You May Enjoy