Which Is Better, a Shower or a Bath?

The bath vs the shower, it’s an age old debate that many homeowners have.

It’s no surprise to us.

Bathrooms rank among the top remodeling projects in the United Kingdom.

This is according to a survey done by the National Association of Home Builders in 2012.

Which Is Better, A Shower Or A Bath

Shower Vs Bathtubs; Pros Vs Cons

Before answering the question of which between the two is better, we need to analyze both. Let’s have a look at the pros and cons of having a bath tub and of having a shower.

Bathtubs; Pros and Cons

Let’s start with the Bath. Here are some pros of having a bathtub in your house:

Great for Relaxation

Which Is Better, A Shower Or A Bath

It’s a well-known secret that bathtubs are a great source of relaxation.

It can be argued that this is what they are known for.

Having a bathtub can be a great way to unwind after a long day.

Ideal for Families

We’re basing our arguments on families with babies and little kids. It’s much easier to clean your kids on a bathtub than a walk in shower. You can get to clean them without having to take a shower yourself. Plus, little kids tend to enjoy bathtubs rather than showers.

Can Fit Almost Anywhere

Hear us out; this applies mostly to the free standing units.

These units tend to be finished on all sides and so can complement any room that they are placed in.

Which Is Better, A Shower Or A Bath

Bathtubs aren’t perfect. They also have their drawbacks. Let’s have a look at some of the cons:

Difficult to Use for Older People and People With Injuries

It’s without a doubt that bathtubs aren’t a great option for older people and people with injuries. These groups prefer walk in showers they can easily step in and out of.

Not Efficient

Bathtubs tend to be inefficient in terms of water and power usage. A lot of water is used when you choose to take a bath when compared to taking a shower. On top of that, a strong water heater or at least one with adequate capacity is required to enjoy a hot bath. This might mean that you use more electricity as well.

Time Consuming

It takes time to fill a bath. To use a tub, you need it to be at least half full, which might take some time. They might be great when you want to relax, but aren’t great when you’re busy or in a hurry.

Shower; Pros and Cons

Let’s have a look at pros and cons of showers. Starting with the Pros.


Which Is Better, A Shower Or A Bath

As far as power and water usage, showers tend to be better when compared to bath tubs.

You use less water and it also doesn’t consume a lot of energy to get hot water from a shower. Howver, there is a lot more steam created, so you will have to ensure you have a bathroom extractor fan installed, check out our guide on these here


There is nothing that you need to fill. Walk in showers are much quicker. You step in and turn on the shower, nothing more to it.

Great for People With Mobility Issues

Old people and People with injuries will find walk in showers more convenient. They are quicker to use and easier to get in and out of.

On the other hand, it does also have its cons:

Not Great for Families

People with kids might not be fans of walk in showers. Kids tend to enjoy bath tubs rather than showers. It’s also easier to clean them in bathtubs as they enjoy it and you won’t necessarily have to get wet.

Requires More Maintenance

In terms of cleaning, showers require more effort. You not only need to clean the shower and tiles but also the shower doors/curtains. You need to do this to avoid calcium stains and lime growth.

Which Will Work Best for You?

As a homeowner, you need to think about the future as well. Which works best for you ROI (Return on Investment)? You need to have a look at the market to realize which group is more likely to buy your house. Many real estate experts advise having at least one tub in the house. This allows you to meet the needs of different buyers within your market.

Related Topics To Read Next

Isolator Switch for Shower Not Working? Here’s Why

Crack in Your Shower Tray? Here’s What to Do

How to Increase Pressure in an Electric Shower

Electric Shower Flow Rate & Other Basics [Shower Basics Guide]

Common Thermostatic Shower Problems & Fixes

Shower Won’t Turn Off? Here’s Why

Shower Pump Not Working? Here’s why

How to Seal a Shower Screen

Airlock In Shower? Here’s What to Do

Triton Shower Low Pressure? Here’s Why

Triton Shower Not Working? Here’s Why

Aqualisa Shower Leaking? Here’s Why

Aqualisa Shower Problems? Here’s Why

Shower Screen Leaking? Try This

Mira Shower Leaking? Here’s Why

Shower Waste Fall & Other Basics

About the Author Harry Thompson

Involved in home renovations throughout his life, Harry is an expert in everything to do with home and garden DIY. In his spare time, he enjoys cooking and tending to his garden.